What happens when the routine that keeps you grounded, confident, and connected to yourself is suddenly interrupted by an injury after 40?
In this episode of the Fuel Your Strength Podcast, Steph Gaudreau talks with strength coach, combat athlete, and student physical therapist Adam Duthie (Gray Beard Black Belt) about the messy middle between being injured and returning to the activities you love.
They explore the physical and psychological realities of rehab, chronic pain, strength training, and returning to sport in your 40s and beyond. From managing fear around movement to why “just rest it” often falls short, this conversation offers practical insights for athletes over 40 who want to stay strong, resilient, and active long-term.
Click play to listen on this page, no app required:
Or listen on your preferred streaming platform: iTunes (Apple Podcasts) | Spotify | YouTube
Want a free week of strength workouts? Click here to get started
What You’ll Learn in This Episode
- Why injury impacts more than just physical pain
- The limits of advice to “just stop training”
- What scans and imaging often don’t reveal
- A more useful way to think about pain and recovery
- Why some athletes stay stuck after injury
- The role of strength training in building resilience
- What many rehab programs miss
- How to stay connected to your sport while recovering
Enjoyed This Episode and Want More?
If this episode resonates and you’re ready to stop guessing in the gym, try a free 7-day sample of Strong with Steph, a progressive strength program designed for athletic women over 40.
Follow Steph on Instagram | YouTube | Facebook
If you liked this episode, please leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts
Related Posts
- Injury, Pain and Physical Therapy Over 40 with Dr. Leada Malek
- Overtraining, Injury and Burnout with Dr. A’Naja Newsome
- Mobility for Strength Training with Dr. Jen Hosler
Coming Back from Injury Over 40 – Episode Transcript
Steph Gaudreau 0:00
When you’re strength training, doing your sport, and living an active life, injuries can still happen. How do you manage the return to the gym, to the sport you love, and protect your mental well-being? That’s what we explore today with special guest Adam Duthie. If you enjoy the show, please subscribe on your favorite podcast platform. Adam is known as Gray Beard Black Belt on Instagram. He’s a strength and conditioning coach who works with older grapplers and combat athletes, a jiu jitsu athlete himself, and a student physical therapist. Today we’re talking about bridging the gap between injury, PT, and getting back to sport while taking care of the psychological toll of being sidelined.
Adam Duthie 1:45
Great to be here.
Steph Gaudreau 1:46
I first noticed you in social conversations and appreciated your thoughtful perspective. If you’ve had surgery or an injury and need to get back to training but feel stuck, this episode is for you.
Adam Duthie 2:56
Yeah, hell yeah. Excited to be here.
Making the Decision to Go Back to Physical Therapy School
Steph Gaudreau 2:58
Adam, you went back to school for PT in your 40s. What motivated that decision?
Adam Duthie 3:27
My path into training wasn’t typical. I worked in gyms for years and eventually returned to school later in life. When hybrid PT programs became more available, it opened the door for me to pursue a PT degree at 44. I wanted to help athletes—especially people in the jiu jitsu community—who often won’t stop training despite injuries. Having been sidelined myself, I understand how damaging that can be mentally, and I wanted to be better equipped to help others stay healthy on the mats.
Steph Gaudreau 5:34
Are you planning to specialize?
Adam Duthie 5:55
I started school open to anything, but my passion is sports. I worked in outpatient ortho and loved seeing athletes—baseball players, skiers, basketball players. I’m heading toward working with athletes and sports-specific rehab rather than cardiopulmonary or neuro specialties.
Common Injuries in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu Grapplers
Steph Gaudreau 7:12
For listeners in their 40s who train, what common issues do you see?
Adam Duthie 8:49
I see two categories: acute traumatic injuries (like ACL tears) with a clear path to rehab, and chronic issues—especially neck and low back problems. Chronic pain affects sleep, work, and identity for active people who tie so much of themselves to training. That psychological burden can be as significant as the physical one.
Steph Gaudreau 10:36
People often feel pressure to train through pain or don’t know how to modify. How do you help someone decide whether to push through, modify, or see a professional?
How Do You Know You Need Physical Therapy?
Adam Duthie 12:37
Many aches resolve on their own, and a good trainer can help you work around them. But if pain becomes chronic and affects sleep, work, or daily function, it’s time to see a clinician. Importantly, focus on activity modification—not total removal. Telling someone to stop all activity without a plan fosters fear and avoidance. If daily life is impaired or you can’t work around the issue, seek guidance.
What is the Meaning of Nocebo Effect?
Steph Gaudreau 14:31
Can you explain the nocebo effect and why fear-based messaging is harmful?
Adam Duthie 14:58
Clinicians and coaches are viewed as authorities. If that authority plants fear—saying that certain sports or lifting are dangerous—it can leave a lasting psychological mark. People may begin to avoid movements or live with an overly negative identity about their body. That avoidance can perpetuate pain and limit recovery.
Should You Rest When Injured?
Steph Gaudreau 16:25
People often rest because symptoms improve. Why can that become a trap?
Adam Duthie 17:21
Reducing load temporarily is valid, but how you communicate it matters. Use graded exposure: regress the activity to a tolerable level and progressively build tolerance. Avoid fear-driven messaging. Describe pain as an experience that doesn’t define the person, provide reassurance, and use gradual load to rebuild tissue resilience.
How Do You Get Over Your Fear of Injury?
Adam Duthie 20:04
Fear can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Overemphasizing risk leads to hypervigilance and increased likelihood of problems. Using reassurance, small challenges, and graded exposure can help people test those beliefs and rebuild confidence in movement.
Steph Gaudreau 20:55
Imaging can also reinforce fear. What are the downsides of scans and MRIs?
Potential Downsides of Imaging
Adam Duthie 21:59
Imaging often reveals findings that are asymptomatic—bulging discs or degenerative changes that many pain-free people have. Imaging doesn’t always change conservative treatment. If you’re pursuing non-surgical care, imaging might not be necessary and can increase anxiety. Use imaging when it will alter treatment decisions, such as when surgery is being considered.
Steph Gaudreau 24:02
Social media amplifies polarized messages about imaging and care. Nuance gets lost, which makes communication harder.
Adam Duthie 25:00
We all chase attention on social platforms, and nuance suffers. I try to ask, “Who does this serve?” and bring context. A good coach or clinician asks many questions before forming an opinion.
Can You Lift Weights After Physical Therapy?
Steph Gaudreau 25:54
Many people finish PT feeling unprepared to return to training. Why does this happen?
Adam Duthie 27:07
Part of the problem is the insurance-driven model that can create a churn-and-burn PT experience. Many clinics are limited by time and reimbursement. Some private clinics do a better job integrating post-PT transitions into strength training. Another issue is that PT education often underemphasizes advanced exercise prescription. Practitioners without a sports or lifting background may struggle to guide athletes back to higher-level training.
Steph Gaudreau 30:19
What should patients ask PTs before being discharged?
Returning to Sports After Injury
Adam Duthie 31:24
Ask for a clear return-to-sport plan with specific benchmarks. There are tests like the Y-balance test, single-leg hop tests, and sport-specific progressions. If your sport has unique demands—like grappling’s upper-body intensity—ask how the plan maps to those demands. Advocate for clarity: ask how each exercise helps you return to your specific activity.
Steph Gaudreau 33:23
Some PTs do this well; others don’t. Be proactive and show videos or describe your sport level so the clinician can tailor the plan.
Steph Gaudreau 34:44
Why should athletes include strength training?
Should Athletes Lift Weights?
Adam Duthie 34:44
Injury happens when force exceeds tissue tolerance. Strength training is the most reproducible way to increase tissue resilience in a controlled environment. It won’t eliminate risk, but it reduces the frequency and severity of injuries. Heavy strength work—relative to your current capacity—is an effective method to build durability. It takes time and consistency, but it’s the most reliable investment you can make to stay active.
Steph Gaudreau 36:47
People worry strength training will hurt them.
Benefits of Strength Training for Athletes
Adam Duthie 37:14
Most injuries happen from doing too much too soon. Build load gradually and consistently. Ask “How do I do this?” rather than “How long will it take?” Show up regularly—attendance is the most important metric. Even short sessions, isometrics, or simple drills throughout the day are better than sporadic effort.
Steph Gaudreau 38:26
How do you help people who think they’re already “lifting” but do inconsistent or ineffective workouts?
Adam Duthie 39:49
I flip it back on them: would you expect to progress in jiu jitsu if you trained once every two months? Consistency is the crucial factor. Structure your environment, keep simple tools at hand, and make training habitual. Even small, regular efforts accumulate into meaningful progress.
Steph Gaudreau 41:45
What training tool is most underrated?
Adam Duthie 42:01
Isometrics. They’re time-efficient, uncomfortable, and underused. Isometrics can maintain or build strength with low volume and minimal fatigue—useful when sport practice ramps up or when you need to protect energy while preserving strength.
Recovering Mentally from a Sports Injury
Steph Gaudreau 43:05
How do you address the psychological side of recovery?
Adam Duthie 43:56
Stay involved in your community. If you can’t train, still be present—go to the gym, sit in the room, watch, support teammates. Keeping your routine and social connections preserves identity and motivation. Isolation fuels catastrophizing. Remaining connected and engaged provides motivation to follow through on rehab and return to sport.
Steph Gaudreau 45:40
Tell listeners where they can find you.
Adam Duthie 45:55
Instagram is best: Graybeard Black Belt. I try to respond to messages and questions there.
Steph Gaudreau 46:17
Thanks, Adam. Great conversation.
Adam Duthie 46:22
Thanks for having me.
Steph Gaudreau 46:23
That wraps this episode of Fuel Your Strength. Adam Duthie (Gray Beard Black Belt) shares practical, nuanced guidance for athletes recovering from injury—especially those in midlife. Check the show notes for links and resources. If you enjoyed the episode, subscribe on your podcast platform. Until next time, stay strong.